Conservative Catholics Push Back Hard on Gay Acceptance

St. Peter's Basilica
St. Peter's Basilica is seen at early morning. Conservative Roman Catholic prelates on Tuesday vowed to change a controversial Vatican document that held out the possibility of a major shift in the Church's attitude toward homosexuals. (Andreas Tille/Wikimedia Commons)

Conservative Roman Catholic prelates on Tuesday vowed to change a controversial Vatican document that held out the possibility of a major shift in the Church's attitude toward homosexuals.

The document, issued on Monday, said homosexuals had "gifts and qualities to offer" and asked if Catholicism could accept gays and recognize positive aspects of same-sex couples.

In a dramatic change in tone from past condemnatory language, it said the Church should challenge itself to find "a fraternal space" for homosexuals without compromising Catholic doctrine on family and matrimony.

The Vatican stressed on Tuesday that the paper was still a "work in progress," and a definitive version would be issued after the meeting of some 200 bishops, known as a synod, ends on Sunday.

Cardinal Raymond Burke, an arch-conservative from the United States, accused liberals in the committee that prepared the text of having railroaded the assembly. He said it did not reflect a consensus position and demanded changes.

"While the document purports to report only the discussion which took place among the synod fathers, it, in fact, advances positions which many synod fathers do not accept ...," he told The Catholic World report.

"A great number of the synod fathers found it objectionable," he said, asking Pope Francis to issue a clear statement defending marriage and the traditional family.

While Roman Catholic gay rights groups around the world hailed the paper as a breakthrough, conservatives condemned it as a betrayal of Church teaching and said its language had sowed confusion among the faithful.

"It [the document] is not what we are saying at all," Cardinal Wilfrid Fox Napier of South Africa told a news conference at the Vatican. "It is not a true message."

"The message has gone out that this is what the synod is saying, that this is what the Catholic Church is saying ... Whatever we say hereafter will seem like we're doing damage control," Napier said.

One source in the synod said a number of other conservative bishops were "disappointed" by the document, known by its Latin name "relatio."

It was written by a committee of bishops after a week of speeches in the closed-door assembly. Participants have now broken down into 10 small discussion groups to submit changes. The final version will serve for further reflection among Catholics around the world over the next 12 months and as the cornerstone of a second and final synod on the family next year.

Cardinal Reinhard Marx of Germany disagreed with the conservatives, calling the document "an honest representation of how the debate developed."

Additional reporting by Tom Heneghan; editing by Crispian Balmer

© 2014 Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved.

To contact us or to submit an article, click here.

Get Charisma's best content delivered right to your inbox! Never miss a big news story again. Click here to subscribe to the Charisma News newsletter.

Charisma News - Informing believers with news from a Spirit-filled perspective