'Tragic' Charlie Gard Case Forces Us to Ask This Basic Question

The father of critically ill baby Charlie Gard carries a toy monkey in his pocket as he and Connie Yates, Charlie Gard's mother, arrive at the High Court in London.
The father of critically ill baby Charlie Gard carries a toy monkey in his pocket as he and Connie Yates, Charlie Gard's mother, arrive at the High Court in London. (REUTERS/Neil Hall)

Charlie Gard has become the current human face of the basic, gut-wrenching debate about who makes end-of-life decisions for human beings.

That's the premise of a new op-ed in LifeZette.com from evangelical leader and president of Southern Evangelical Seminary (SES) Dr. Richard Land about the case of 11-month-old Charlie, his parents' desperate wishes to save his life and a health care system exerting control.

"We must not allow ourselves to get lost in the medical, technical and legal jargon of this tragic case," Land wrote. "The Charlie Gard case is at the crux of the titanic debate raging throughout Western civilization of those advocating the historic 'sanctity of life' ethic, versus those who are espousing a 'quality of life' ethic. However, the Charlie Gard case is adjudicated ultimately, this crucial debate will continue, and it has enormous implications for end-of-life decisions for tens of millions of terminally ill patients at all stages of life."

Today in London, a U.S. doctor is examining Charlie, as the debate to save his life or allow him to "die with dignity" rages on.

"The advocates of the quality of life ethic are asserting that Charlie does not have a life worthy of living," Land continued. "The Third Reich called it 'lebensunwertes leben.' The merciful and humane thing to do for such people, therefore, is let them die—a sort of 'death therapy.' The sanctity of life ethic asserts that Charlie Gard is a human being and, as such, has an inherent right to life no matter how perilous or incurable his medical condition.

"Furthermore," Land added, "sanctity of life proponents argue that withdrawing his life support system is an active measure that is the moral equivalent of euthanasia or mercy killing. It is analogous to what Pope John Paul II meant when he stated that the withdrawal of basic nutrition and hydration, via a feeding tube, from a comatose patient is 'euthanasia by other means.'"

The tragic situation, especially for Charlie's parents, has also brought to light the consequences of government health care and socialized medicine.

"A basic question in this case is who should have the ultimate authority to make the decision concerning Charlie's fate—his parents or the government?" Land asks. "Historically, in Western civilization and particularly in the English-speaking world, that final decision-making authority has been vested with the parents, not the government. The only real legal precedent to the contrary has been if the parents are denying a child life-saving medical treatment, such as blood transfusions, because of religious convictions.

"Charlie Gard's case also has enormous implications relating to current health care debates here in America," he continued. "When the government runs health care, as it does in the single-payer National Health Service system in Britain, the supposedly 'free' guaranteed access to health care is anything but free. First, consumers pay taxes for care. More importantly, perhaps the biggest price you pay with government-run health care is to surrender your autonomy to decide what is the best health care for you and your children's welfare—a terrible price indeed. Although Charlie Gard may be severely, perhaps terminally, medically challenged, he is forever his parents' little boy—and they love and cherish him. They should have the right to seek whatever care they think may help him. How dare government bureaucrats say otherwise."

Land also talks about the Charlie Gard case on today's installment of "Bringing Every Thought Captive," a two-minute radio feature that airs on nearly 800 stations nationwide. Listen here.

Get Charisma's best content delivered right to your inbox! Never miss a big news story again. Click here to subscribe to the Charisma News newsletter.

Incredible Savings, Inspiration and Encouragement from CHARISMA:

  • End Of The Year - Bible Sale!: Click Here to save up to 50% off a great selection of Bibles. Plus, get a free gift with each order!
  • Big Discounts On Book Bundles & Gifts: Click Here to view all our bundles and save up to 72%! Prayer, Holy Spirit, Anointing, and more.
  • FREE eCourses by CHARISMA: Click Here to view all eight of our free courses. Topics include Fear, Forgiveness, Holy Spirit, Supernatural, and How to Hear God.
  • Women Of God: Rise up and enter the anointing of Deborah, Anna, Esther, Ruth and Hannah. You were called to go higher. Click Here to learn more.
  • Prayer Changes Everything! John Eckhardt's prayer bundle gives you six powerful books to help you pray and change any situation. Click Here.

Subscription Special: Subscribe to Charisma for two years for Only $29.97 and get two free gifts. Gift #1 Chayil by John Eckhardt. Gift #2 Chosen by Michelle McClain-Walters. View Offer

Charisma News - Informing believers with news from a Spirit-filled perspective